Fast delivery

Get in as fast as 1 hour

It’s all local

Shop your favorites

Direct chat

Connect with shoppers

White Button Mushrooms Delivery or Pickup

The Instacart guide to white button mushrooms


About white button mushrooms

White button mushrooms (Agaricus Bisporus) are probably most people's idea of what an edible mushroom looks like and are the most cultivated mushroom varieties globally. It is closely related to Portobello and Crimini mushrooms, with the only differences being age and color. The white button mushroom is an extremely popular mushroom eaten by millions of people every day, making up 90% of mushrooms consumed in the United States. 

White button mushrooms are a great source of protein that also provides a variety of nutritional value. One cup (96 grams) includes:
  • Antioxidants
  • Vitamin D
  • Vitamin B2
  • Vitamin B9
  • Phosphorous
  • Manganese
  • Potassium
  • Zinc

How to pick out white button mushrooms 

A distinguishing feature of white button mushrooms is brown gills underneath their white caps. If you're picking up your mushrooms, look out for young pieces with no signs of damage or bruising to them.

Since fresh mushrooms have a limited shelf-life of three to four days, try freezing, canning, and drying methods to extend their shelf life without sacrificing nutritional quality. You can eat these mushrooms fresh, dried, fried, or raw. If you have dried mushrooms, you can rehydrate them by soaking them in water.

White button mushroom cooking tips

One of the reasons why white button mushrooms are so successful in the kitchen is that you can use them in almost any recipe, opening up a world of possibilities. They keep flavor well and are much more adaptable in the kitchen than other wild mushrooms.

When cleaning them, remember that too much time in water runs the risk of making them mushy. So clean them with just a quick rinse or damp cloth. Pat them dry before cooking to ensure a crispier and firmer result when cooking. For storage, they last longer in your fridge than any other type of mushroom. It is better to store them in a paper bag than in plastic, to allow aeration of the mushrooms and retain freshness, as white button mushrooms generally contain a lot of moisture. 

White button mushrooms are best suited for applications such as baking, roasting, sauteing, grilling, or stewing. 
  • Slice them and add them raw to your favorite green or grain salad.
  • Slice them raw and serve in a dip.
  • Saute them with olive oil, salt, and pepper for a side of cooked mushrooms.
  • Add them to a stir-fry along with other vegetables. 
  • Grill them on skewers as an accompaniment to your barbecue.
  • Add them to your sauces and gravies.
  • Stuff them with cheese and your choice of meat for a delicious appetizer. 
  • Roast them at 350⁰F with rosemary and thyme for a crunchy snack. 
  • Make a hearty and healthy mushroom broth by boiling them with carrots, leeks, garlic, and onions. 
  • Add them as a topping to your favorite pizza.
  • Cook them with scrambled eggs or add them as a filling to an omelet for a healthy breakfast.
  • Make a classic mushroom soup with butter and cream.
White button mushrooms pair well with tomatoes, carrots, celery, potatoes, garlic, onion, cheese, pasta, shallots, rice, and sauces, among other ingredients. 

Whether you're making a stew or adding it to your homemade pizza, mushrooms are a great ingredient to have at home that gives dishes an extra spark. You can quickly get them along with any other ingredients you may want to pair them with via Instacart!

White Button Mushrooms Near Me

Buy your favorite White Button Mushrooms online with Instacart. Order White Button Mushrooms from local and national retailers near you and enjoy on-demand, contactless delivery or pickup within 2 hours.

FAQs about white button mushrooms

They are all Agaricus Bisporus, just different ages. Button mushrooms are small, white mushrooms. They are the youngest, followed by Cremini mushrooms that are more aged and brown, then Portobellos, which are brown and the most aged mushroom. As the mushroom matures, they lose some of their water content, making them browner.

The simple answers to this question are yes and no.

They are suitable for you because they are an excellent protein source and provide a range of minerals and vitamins, including vitamin D, which UV light exposure enhances. 

However, Agaricus Bisporus and all other edible mushrooms contain a small number of irritating compounds. These include hydrazine, a group of carcinogenic chemicals. The good news, however, is that this small amount of chemicals is significantly reduced by cooking. For this reason, cooking your mushrooms is widely recommended. The heat from cooking has the additional benefit of breaking down the mushroom's cell walls, which are harder to digest if eaten raw, so cooking them makes it easier on your digestive system.

Instacart is an on-demand grocery delivery service that delivers groceries and other household essentials from over 300 grocers and retailers to customers' doorsteps in the US and Canada. Fill up your cart using the Instacart app or visit our online store from your home's convenience and get your groceries delivered to you safely on the same day!